Chinese Reviews Reviews

Documentary Review: A Family in the Sinkhole (2018) by Yao Zubiao

When we think about the conflict between two generations, the concept may strike you as one which seems unnecessarily aggressive, confrontational, or at the very least a symbol for an unbridgeable gap between people. Indeed, while one generation may define aspects such as family, home and responsibility differently than the other, this does not automatically result in a generational chasm. However, the cracks within the relationship of people become visible, the subject of unspoken words and accusations, perhaps even visible if you dare look closer at certain family portraits. Of course, many of these conflicts may never come to the surface, but they are bottled up inside, and if the right moment arrives, who knows how and if they erupt.

A Family in the Sinkhole” is screening at Chinesisches Filmfest München (Munich)

The fact the family unit and its conflicts have always been a reflection of social shifts and developments is at the core of Chinese director 's “”, his final project for his degree at Beijing Film Academy. Over the course of several months, he and his crew have accompanied the inhabitants of Da Guoquan, China's biggest sinkhole which is 600m wide and 150m deep. Used as a leper colony a long time ago, it is a dense forest and a small village with approximately 32 people living there.

In recent years, the place has been discovered by tourists and backpackers exploring its natural beauty and visiting the village. While the younger generation, such as Yang Xiuxiang welcomes them and realizes the opportunity for the place and its people, the older generation, for instance, his mother, 74-year-old He Pingxiu, is unwilling to adapt. As local authorities start coming up with a development plan for the village demanding a lot of changes from its inhabitants, the conflict between the young and the old starts to escalate.

Although the camera occasionally captures moments of everyday comedy, as the film progresses the depth of the generational conflict becomes visible. While the argument between mother and son about how to keep a pig, how to make a farmhouse look presentable and in general, be more hygienic may look rather comical at first, as a viewer you start to realize what is at stake here. Essentially, there are two ways of living fighting with each other over the smallest of detail: the one unwilling to let go of a secluded life in peace, the other ready for some kind of progress and more connection to the outside world.

Over the course of its running time of 71 minutes, Yao Zubiao's camera never takes sides, stays neutral while at the same time focusing on each of these sides, weighing the possible pros and cons of the decision and conflict at hand. In the end, we have to understand his film, perhaps as an example, a mirror of a much wider development within a country facing a shift in many aspects; from politics to society, one which will not happen silently, but is necessary. Development, or “devilment” as He Pingxiu remarks in one scene, is inevitable, but there is the question of how will be left behind, or if we simply return to an old way of doing things.

In conclusion, “A Family in a Sinkhole” is an interesting film about the conflict between maintaining an old system of values or standards and the way towards progress. While the decision may seem simple to us, the repercussions are quite severe, testing the unity of a family as Yao Zubiao's film shows.

About the author

Rouven Linnarz

Ever since I watched Takeshi Kitano's "Hana-Bi" for the first time (and many times after that) I have been a cinephile. While much can be said about the technical aspects of film, coming from a small town in Germany, I cherish the notion of art showing its audience something which one does normally avoid, neglect or is unable to see for many different reasons. Often the stories told in films have helped me understand, discover and connect to something new which is a concept I would like to convey in the way I talk and write about films. Thus, I try to include some info on the background of each film as well as a short analysis (without spoilers, of course), an approach which should reflect the context of a work of art no matter what genre, director or cast. In the end, I hope to pass on my joy of watching film and talking about it.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter