Reviews Shorts Reviews Vietnamese Reviews

Short Film Review: The Graduation of Edison (2019) by Pham Hoang Minh Thy

It sparkles just that much joy and adds the "but" after what would simply be praise.

” plays around the themes of fitting in, being accepted for what you are, and, no less important, accepting yourself.

There are many strange and peculiar places in the world. Some discovered, some still hidden. Perhaps you have seen it, perhaps you have visited it. brings you to a small village, where shortly after one`s birth, a tree grows on your head. You should take care of it until you reach 18 and graduate. Then, as a part of the ceremony, the tree is cut and planted into the earth. As odd as it sounds, it makes becoming an adult quite fanciful. But what if things don't exactly go as expected?

The Graduation of Edison is screening at the Osaka Asian Film Festival.

Minh () is ten and is the only kid in the class with no tree. Feeling excluded, he spends his time with his only friend – his sister Edison (). He even writes an essay about her. Without a tree, Minh is excluded from all the fun with classmates, gets laughed at. You bet he would do anything to grow one. His sister, for a change, is already graduating and doesn't feel ready to cut off hers. Even less as the tree goes full bloom. As much as this makes them two peas in a pod in the eyes of their classmates, their visible difference soon becomes an issue.

“The Graduation of Edison” sets up a romantic and breezy mood. Yet, it plays around the themes of fitting in, being accepted for what you are, and, no less important, self-acceptance. Moreover, it strides the family chord and the idea of sticking for your sibling. Nonetheless, the loose, romantic approach to the storytelling wanders off and dilutes the core ideas. Including the little play on Edison and Tesla that might be dangerous in certain regions of Europe.

In the end, Pham presents a film that is sweet and touching, and overall nice. That, however, leaves it too loose in the grip on its ideas. As “The Graduation of Edison” spends time building up the ambiance, the focus spreads in too many directions. Consequently, it sparkles just that much joy and adds the “but” after what would simply be praise.

About the author

Anomalilly

Hello everyone! Ever since I was a kid, I wanted to be an actress. I absolutely adored Greta Garbo. Far from her looks and even further from her talents, I ditched acting as a professional career option and went for film studies.
It must have been sometimes in my early teens, which is still too late if you look at the origin stories of my colleagues, I fell for action cinema and cinemas of the Far East. Depending on who asks, the answer to "why" question is either: 1/ The lighting style just hit me in the guts, or 2/ Have you really seen those men? (Up until now, I would welcome Han Suk-kyu to read me anything.)
I program the Asian sidebars "Eastern Promises" at Art Film Fest Košice and "Queer Asia" for Slovak Queer Film Festival. Both in Slovakia. I come from there.
Oh, and I talk quite a lot.
So long, and thanks for all the fish.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

>